Pinterest vs. Instagram: Which Is Better for Your Business?
If you’re a business owner trying to decide where to focus your marketing energy—Pinterest or Instagram—it’s important to understand how these platforms work very differently. While they’re both visual, their purpose, audience behavior, and impact on your business are not the same.
So, which one is better for you? Let’s break it down.
How They Work:
Instagram is a social platform built for engagement and connection. Think stories, reels, comments, likes—it's all about real-time content. But that content fades quickly unless it goes viral.
Pinterest, on the other hand, is a visual search engine. Users come to Pinterest to discover, plan, and save ideas—and your content can live on the platform for months or even years, driving traffic long after it’s posted.
Audience Intent
When someone scrolls Instagram, they’re typically looking for inspiration or entertainment.
That’s great for brand awareness and community-building.
But Pinterest users? They’re planners and buyers. They're actively searching for things like “branding ideas for small businesses” or “Pinterest marketing tips”—which means their intent is higher and more conversion-focused. This is gold for service providers, product sellers, and content creators.
Traffic & Conversions
If your goal is to drive traffic to your website, Pinterest wins—hands down. You can link every pin directly to your blog, sales page, freebie, or product. Instagram has limited link capability (one bio link and a few story links if you meet criteria).
Pinterest is built to send users off the platform, while Instagram is built to keep users on the platform. That difference can make or break your traffic strategy.
What’s Best for Your Business?
Use Instagram if you want to build a community, share behind-the-scenes content, and connect on a more personal level.
Use Pinterest if you want consistent, long-term traffic to your website, blog, or shop—and to reach users with buying intent.
Ideally, both platforms can work together, but if your time is limited and you need traffic that converts, Pinterest is a powerhouse worth investing in.
Need help getting started with Pinterest? Let’s chat! I offer Pinterest strategy and management services to help small business owners grow without the stress.
Want to learn more about Marketing Using Pinterest?
Download my Online Course and Start Learning How!
